pCall Us: (317) 298-7500

About Us


McClain Matthews Insurance has been servicing the Indianapolis insurance community since 1948. As an Independent Insurance Agency, we represent some of the top insurance companies in the country. That means we find the company that best fits your needs at a great price.

Your home, you business, your family . . . your life. At McClain Matthews Insurance, it is about creating the insurance coverage to fit your life We promise:

  • Analysis of your complete insurance needs
  • A responsible protection plan designed just for you
  • Products and companies selected to best suit your specific needs
  • A competitively priced proposal created just for you
  • Fair, prompt settlement of claims
  • Periodic review of your insurance needs
  • Budget plans and other ways to save money and meet your financial needs
McClain Matthews Insurance wants you to know about the insurance you are buying. If you have questions, we will be happy to answer them. It what you should expect and it is what we promise to deliver.


  • I have worked with Karl for years both professionally and on personal projects. Karl can be counted on in all situations and works hard to find to find value for his clients. I have worked with several agents and advisers for personal needs and for business. No one is better than Karl.

    Eric Tinsley, Vice President Service Delivery at Allegient, LLC  

  • Karl Buetow has become a trusted Insurance expert to our family. I consult him on coverage options and he makes sure we get what we need. I never have to worry about being taken advantage of by insurance providers because Karl's integrity is unquestioned. He is a good man and a servant to the community. I am happy to recommend him to you for your insurance needs.

    Scott Tyring, Senior Pastor at Chesterton United Methodist Church

Our Agents

  • Karl P. Buetow
  • Ginger Griego
  • Casi “CJ” App
  • Dena Pattyn