pCall Us: (317) 298-7500

McClain Matthews Insurance

McClain Matthews Insurance

Since 1948, McClain Matthews Insurance has been servicing the Indianapolis community. As an Independent Insurance Agency, we represent some of the top insurance companies in the country. That means we find the company that best fits your needs at a great price.

Learn more.

Auto rates from companies competing for you!

Auto rates from companies competing for you!

When it comes to insuring your car, truck or any family vehicle, you can't afford to make the wrong insurance choice. The last thing you want to hear from your agent is "Sorry but that isn't covered under you policy." You may think you are saving a few dollars now but it can cost you later.

Learn more.

Contractors, we have you covered.

Contractors, we have you covered.

McClain Matthews has been covering Indianapolis contractors for decades. Our experience with large and small contractors assures you that we have the ability to design coverage to fit your particular situation. We will review all aspects of your business, determine the coverage you need and then find best provider to meet your needs.

Learn more.

Specializing in small business coverages

Specializing in small business coverages

McClain Matthews offers a variety of commercial lines of insurance that can provide the coverage for small to medium-size business operations. Property and liability protection can be packaged into one policy, ensuring you convenience and a custom fit that’s perfect for your business.

Learn more.

Homeowners

home owners insurance


Everyone knows that if you own your home you need insurance.But who needs the hassle of dealing with multiple companies and agents. McClain Matthews can shop your homeowners insurance to several insurance companies to find you the best deal and coverage.

Read more.

You have choices.

Your insurance choices


Most insurance agents think their company provides the right solution for all you insurance needs. We represent a number of companies allowing us to find the right company for your specific need.

Read more.

Your financial future.

Your financial future.


Insurance is more than just covering your home and auto against loss. Insurance can insure your financial futures. Many insurance products help secure your long-term financial stability and prosperity. Life insurance, mortgage protection, and retirement plans all help protect your financial future.

Read more.

Contact an agent today.

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Your Phone (required)

Coverage Type

Your Message

captcha

Type the characters in the image above

Testimonials

  • I have worked with Karl for years both professionally and on personal projects. Karl can be counted on in all situations and works hard to find to find value for his clients. I have worked with several agents and advisers for personal needs and for business. No one is better than Karl.

    Eric Tinsley, Vice President Service Delivery at Allegient, LLC  

  • Karl Buetow has become a trusted Insurance expert to our family. I consult him on coverage options and he makes sure we get what we need. I never have to worry about being taken advantage of by insurance providers because Karl's integrity is unquestioned. He is a good man and a servant to the community. I am happy to recommend him to you for your insurance needs.

    Scott Tyring, Senior Pastor at Chesterton United Methodist Church